For prize-winning flavor, serve the perfect spread in Amish Farmhouse Kitchens Pumpkin Butter (18 oz.). From time-honored Amish recipes to the true care dedicated to every small batch, Amish Farmhouse Kitchens are not just for special occasions, but to make every occasion special! Pumpkin Butter (18 oz.) Ingredients: Pumpkin white sugar brown sugar water spices vinegar salt bisulfate of soda.